The Confusion Of The Mind Vs The Brain
At the same White House conference mentioned above, Dr. Steven Hyman said these words:
We have also learned some very important facts about these illnesses, and if I can just encapsulate them briefly, its that these are real illnesses of a real organthe brain. Just like coronary artery disease is a disease of a real organthe heart. We can make diagnoses, and these diseases are treatable.
Note, Dr. Hyman is speaking of the immaterial mind at a Mental Health conference, referring to the mind as an organ. If you confuse the two, as Dr. Hyman has done, then you will confuse the treatment of people. Let me say that againif you misunderstand people, then you will misunderstand how to help people. Therein lies one of the greatest dangers of misunderstanding the mind versus the brain.
Next Question Of The Month
The next question is: Is There A God? Answers should be less than 400 words. One word answers will be filed in the bin. Subject lines or envelopes should be marked Question Of The Month, and must be received by 16th April. If you want the chance of getting a book, please include your physical address. You will be edited.
Article tools
How Are The Mind And The Brain Different
After individually analyzing what they are, surely the differences between the two terms have been more than clear. Even so, in case you want or need to have the information with a more visual and easy-to-process character, we have prepared the following selection of the most important differences between the brain and the human mind in the form of key points.
You May Like: Clinical Mental Health Counseling Jobs
Functionalism And Identity Theory
It has commonly been thought that the identity theory has beensuperseded by a theory called functionalism. It could beargued that functionalists greatly exaggerate their difference fromidentity theorists. Indeed some philosophers, such as Lewis and Jackson, Pargetter and Prior , have seen functionalismas a route towards an identity theory.
Take Control Of Your Mind
Theres no good reason to feel isolated or to be in competition with other people based on something youre born with. You have the brain you have, and its a useless activity to make comparisons about something that you cant really control.
What you do have control over is what you do with your mind. You can learn how to ask really great questions and get the full value of other peoples experiences and ideas. Theres a massive amount of thinking in the world thats available to you every day. All of this knowledge and these ideas are opportunities to grow.
Also Check: Most Effective Mental Health Treatment
Type And Token Identity Theories
The notion type and token here comes byanalogy from type and token as applied towords. A telegram love and love and love contains onlytwo type words but in another sense, as the telegraph clerk wouldinsist, it contains five words . Similarly aparticular pain according to the tokenidentity theory is identical to a particular brain process. Afunctionalist could agree to this. Functionalism came to be seen as animprovement on the identity theory, and as inconsistent with it,because of the correct assertion that a functional state can berealised by quite different brain states: thus a functional state mightbe realised by a silicon based brain as well as by a carbon basedbrain, and leaving robotics or science fiction aside, my feeling oftoothache could be realised by a different neural process from whatrealises your toothache.
If we continue to concern ourselves with first order properties, wecould say that the type-token distinction is not an all or nothingaffair. We could say that human experiences are brain processes of onelot of sorts and Alpha Centaurian experiences are brain processes ofanother lot of sorts. We could indeed propose much finerclassifications without going to the limit of mere tokenidentities.
What Is The Difference Between The Mind And The Brain
So what exactly is the difference between the mind and the brain? Well, the mind is separate, yet inseparable from, the brain.
The mind uses the brain, and the brain responds to the mind. The mind also changes the brain. People choose their actionstheir brains do not force them to do anything. Yes, there would be no conscious experience without the brain, but experience cannot be reduced to the brain’s actions.
The mind is energy, and it generates energy through thinking, feeling, and choosing. It is our aliveness, without which, the physical brain and body would be useless.That means we are our mind, and mind-in-action is how we generate energy in the brain.
This is a major part of the activity we pick up with brain technology. When we generate this mind energy through thinking, feeling, and choosing, we build thoughts, which are physical structures in our brain made of proteins. This building of thoughts creates structural changes in the brain, called neuroplasticity1.
In my recent clinical trials, we saw how energy in the brain changed as the subject was thinking, stimulating neuroplasticity. The brain was responding to the person’s stream-of-consciousness and nonconscious activity.
Recommended Reading: What Does The Right Side Of Brain Control
The Mind Is The Reflection Of The Cognitive Processes That Occur In The Brain
We say that the mind emerges from the brain because, despite being an inevitably abstract concept that designates a hypothetical non-physical and intangible reality, it is a reflection of the neural connections that are a physical reality and that, taking place in the brain, generate the neurological processes that, at the of human experience, they manifest as what we call “mind.”
Dont Neuroscientists Say That The Mind Is Just The Brain
Many scientists believe that, not because of evidence, but because they are materialists. The evidence does not point in that direction. Thinking it through carefully, the idea doesnt even make sense, as Michael Egnorpoints out: How do we believe that there are no beliefs? If eliminative materialism is true, then their own belief in eliminative materialism isnt a belief. Its a physical state, a certain concentration of neurochemicals that we foolishly call a belief. So a disagreement between an eliminative materialist and a dualist isnt really a disagreement at all. Its just two different concentrations of brain dopamine or whatever. Exactly how these chemicals in different skulls get into a disagreement is left vague. At this point, you may get a bit uncomfortable, as you would if the guy youre sitting next to on the subway starts talking about the fact that CNN is broadcasting directly into his brain.
In fact, the minds reality is consistent with neuroscience. Its not popular with neuroscientists but that is a different matter. Incidentally, the mind cannot just emerge from the brain if the two have no qualities in common.
Recommended Reading: Spine And Brain Neurosurgery Center
The Mind Is Energy Flow
While the brain can be seen and touched, the mind cannot be defined by the five senses. Instead, the mind is the culmination of energy flow through the brain that occurs when we think, feel, and make decisions . Dr. Caroline Leaf is a cognitive neuroscientist and communication pathologist who has extensively studied the relationship between mind and brain, and has found that the mind works through the brain but remains its own entity.
Through clinical trials, Dr. Leaf has determined that the thoughts we have cultivate physical structures made of proteins in our brains, and consequently lead to structural changes in the brain. This phenomenon is known as neuroplasticity. So while the mind can’t be seen or touched, the energy flow that comprises the mind creates physical interactions within the brain.
Encyclopedia Britannica defines the mind as the faculties involved in cognitive functions like making decisions, recalling memories, evaluating situations, and perceiving. The definition can be extended to include the mind as encompassing sensations, emotions, desires, and experiences within the unconscious. This is aligned with Dr. Leaf’s research findings that the mind is energy flow, comprising a stream of nonconscious activity as we sleep, and streams of conscious and unconscious activity when we’re awake . Her clinical findings define the mind as being characterized by energetic actions including feeling, thinking, and choosing.
When Does The Mind Make The Body Sick
Psychosomatic illnesses are those that, with strong emotional processes, such as depression, anxiety or stress, physical symptoms are derived. It is simply an imbalance between the body and the mind, which causes a decrease in defenses and, therefore, that we are more vulnerable to external agents.
Recommended Reading: Sleep Deprivation And Mental Health
The Long Standing Debate
This dualism gets at a profound philosophical issue that has divided scholars for decades: what is the most productive and helpful level of explanation for mental activity? When do we go too far in reducing mental matters to physically observable activity? Is it more illuminating, for instance, to explain why Teresa loves Dave by invoking their personalities and histories and tastes, or their brain neurons? Consider trying to explain confirmation bias, in which people remember examples that support their point of viewYou never take out the garbage!and forget counterexamples. Is it more illuminating to explain it as the result of the human need to shore up our beliefs or by invoking synapses and neurochemicals?
One case for mind talk is that we have access to our mind. We can recognize and describe what we know, remember, and think. We do not have access to our brain: we cannot tell which regions are active during particular activities.
One case for mind talk is that we have access to our mind. We can recognize and describe what we know, remember, and think.
I dont know about you, but learning that people who are good at understanding things from someone elses perspective tend to be more altruistic doesnt tell me much about altruism that I didnt already suspect. I mean, did anyone think altruistic people would turn out to be bad at perspective taking?
Be Good To Your Brain
So what can you do for your brain? Plenty.
- Eat healthy foods that contain vitamins and minerals. These nutrients are important for the nervous system.
- Do a lot of functional activities, exercise.
- Wear a helmet while riding or playing any outdoor sports to protect your head.
- Dont take drugs, alcohol, or tobacco.
- Use your brain by reading, playing music, making art, brain games.
Read Also: Brain Scan For Mental Illness
Is A Brain Really Needed For Thinking
Thats a good question. At the animal level, maybe not. The blob, now on display at the Paris Zoo, engages in complex behavior without a brain. So does the flatworm and the amoeba and so do the many plant communications networks. One can fairly argue that they arent really thinking. But the conundrum around consciousness makes it difficult to say more than that they probably arent conscious, in the human sense, though many may be sentient . Even a human being, as we saw above, can get by with surprisingly little brain or brain function and actually be conscious in the human sense.
What Does Mind Mean
If you say your mind is not good at the moment, then it only means that your thoughts are not good at the moment. Similarly, if you say that your mind is active then it would mean that you are clear in the mind. The mind bereft of thoughts is an active mind. Mind is without dimensions. It is the result of electrical impulsions across the brain. Mind has no definite place within the body. Philosophers understand the mind altogether as a different concept. They call it different from the body. It cannot be the soul either. It is a separate entity. Mind cannot be touched and studied. This is so because it is not made of any material. You can see the brain, but you cannot see the mind. It is invisible. Mind is a conglomeration of thoughts, memories and the like. Mind can be active one day and can be dull on some other day. Mind is akin to a computer that receives information from various sources. The sources can be anything ranging from your day to day experiences to your memories of the past. These thoughts and memories are translated into action later. The brain ultimately takes the credit for all your actions, good or bad. It is the mind that resides within the brain that does all the thinking and memorizing.
Recommended Reading: The Power Of Your Subconscious Mind Review
The Relationship Between The Brain And The Mind
OK, so now youre clear on the differences and know the brain is a physical organ one can physically look at, touch and study. You also know this isnt the case with the mind. Thus, lets get into how they connect in order to work together.
The work that the brain and the mind do is actually really wonderful. For example, youre trying to reach an object and you think about it. Thus, the brain receives that signal from your mind, activates the necessary nerves and the arm executes the movements.
Your mind conceives your thoughts but the brain follows up with the actual work or process at the physical level.
Find out why Hydration is Essential for Your Brain
A Head Start Advantage: Understanding The Difference Between Mind And Brain
Theres a lot of talk about intelligence today. Parents worry about whether their children are going to be intelligent enough, and theres a mania about getting them into the right schools and starting their training at the earliest possible age to improve their intelligence. Then, theres the worry about competition, that some people are more intelligent than others.
Whenever theres a lot of angst about a particular topic, I realize that we need to create some definitions that make it simpler to think about so we can see very clearly where growth opportunities lie.
Don’t Miss: First Aid Mental Health Training
The Brain Is A Physical Entity
The brain is a physical organ that exists within the shield of the skull and is surrounded by protective fluid . The human brain is comprised of over 100 billion nerves that are constantly communicating to the entire body via trillions of connections known as synapses. As one of the biggest and most complex organs in our bodies, the brain controls the functioning of our bodies through four lobes. The temporal lobe controls auditory functions and memory the parietal lobe allows the body to feel sensations and maintains body positioning the frontal lobe controls judgment, problem-solving, and motor functioning and the occipital lobe commands visual processing.
An average adult brain weighs approximately three pounds . While the brain sends communication through trillions of synapses, it receives communication through the five senses, which are taste, touch, sight, smell, and hearing. After receiving information through our senses, our brains are able to dictate to the rest of our bodies what needs to be done to ensure our survival, from breathing to the movement of our limbs to the storage of memory and knowledge. LiveScience reports that human brains have been studied in medical cadaver labs. Since the brain is an organ that can be physically touched and seen by the human eye, it is definitively a tangible structure.
What Is The Mind
The most puzzling and intangible thing related to the brain is the mind. Mind is all about thoughts, feelings, emotions, spirits, wills, imagination, memory and perception. It is an embodied spirit.
Mind is how we understand and think about a certain function commanded by the brain.
Aristotle describes the connection between the brain and the mind in his book De anima :
Have not we already disposed of the difficulty about interaction involving a common element, when we said that mind is in a sense potentially whatever is thinkable, though actually, it is nothing until it has thought? What it thinks must be in it just as characters may be said to be on a writing tablet on which as yet nothing actually stands written: this is exactly what happens with mind.
The mental actions are buried in our brain, but how we recall, understand, and take actions is the functioning of our mind. The brain gives input, but our mind always gives output.
You May Like: Nami National Alliance On Mental Illness
The Brain Is Studied By Biology The Mind By Psychology And Philosophy
The brain is a physical organ, so it can be studied by biological sciences, such as pure Biology or Neurology, as well as Genetics, Medicine , Biochemistry or other fields derived from Biology.
The mind, on the other hand, being an abstract concept not measurable through the scientific method, cannot be studied by these disciplines. In this context, everything that has to do with the human mind is reflected within both Psychology and Philosophy, specifically in the branch of Philosophy of Mind.
Are The Mind And Brain The Same Is There A Difference Between The Mind And Soul
Mind, Brain and Soul !
Questioner: Is the mind considered a brain?
Dadashri: No, no the mind is a different thing altogether. Its existence is separate altogether. The brain is just a machine it is mechanical. Mind is the mind. The mind has its own existence.
Questioner: What is the difference between the Soul and the mind?
Dadashri: The Soul and the mind have nothing to do with each other . Just as this body is physical, the mind too is physical, and so is speech. The Soul is complete Chetan , the absolute Self it is free of paramanu .
Questioner: What is the difference between the mind, the Soul and the brain?
Dadashri: The mind is a part of the inner-self . Then there is the brain it works continuously. But as per karmic account within, say at three minutes past three, the account comes into the brain through vyavasthit and from the brain it gets discharged through the mind. So you have a thought. When the thought occurs, the entanglement of thought continues, during that time it is all mind, and Atma knows all this. The one that Knows all these thoughts is the Self. What gets engrossed in the thoughts is not the Self. When there is engrossment, the Selfs power goes down and , that is called jivatma . And the pure Self continues to Know all that is happening within at that time one is pure Self Shuddhatma.
Questioner: Please explain about how the mind and Soul can unite and become one.
Dadashri: Yes, only then there is light that is correct.
Read Also: Earth Minded Rain Barrel Plastic 45 Gal
