Mental Health Background Checks For Firearm Ownership


Share post:

They Fall Under A Broader Category Of Mental Illness

Mental Health Expert Voices Concern over Current Firearm Background Checks

According to federal law, individuals cannot buy a gun if a court or other authority has deemed them a mental defective or committed them involuntarily to a mental hospital. Only a handful of states prohibit broader categories of people with mental illness from obtaining a gun.

If they have been ordered to outpatient treatment

If a guardian has been appointed to manage their affairs

If they have been voluntarily admitted to a mental hospital

If they have demonstrated threats or been given other certain diagnoses

Gun Violence And Mental Illness

While most people who are violent do not suffer from mental illnesses, and people with a mental illness are much more likely to be the victims rather than the perpetrators of violence, a 2021 study published in the Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology found that many mass shooters in the United States were living with an untreated mental illness at the time they committed their crime.

The paper showed that people with schizophrenia are less violent than the rest of the population except if theyre unmedicated. The mass shooters turn out to be people with psychiatric illness who are unmedicated, Ira D. Glick, MD, lead researcher and professor emeritus of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Stanford University School of Medicine, tells Verywell.

After analyzing 35 mass shootings in the United States between 1982 and 2019, in which the shooters survived and went to trial, Glick found that 28 shooters had mental illness diagnoses, including:

These should be referred to as brain illnesses rather than mental illnesses because mental illness covers so much ground, says Glick.

He adds that his research shows the need to find a way for people who are selling guns to make sure they dont get in the hands of people who have brain illness and dont want to take medicine.

Confronting The Inevitability Myth: Saving Lives From Gun Suicide

However, federal law cannot require states to make information identifying these people available to the federal or state agencies that perform background checks,2 and many states fail to voluntarily report the necessary records to the FBIs National Instant Criminal Background Check System , especially with respect to people prohibited from possessing guns for mental health reasons. As a result, some individuals known to pose a serious risk to themselves and others can pass background checks and obtain firearms.

Don’t Miss: Recipes For The Mind Diet

Uvalde Was A Mental Health Desert Before A School Shooting Prompted Texas To Respond With Resources

Officials with the Texas Department of Public Safety, which under the 2009 law is charged with collecting mental health records from local courts and passing them along to the FBI for inclusion in NICS, said that the agency routinely reports juvenile criminal records but not juvenile mental health records. Local courts do not provide DPS with juvenile mental health data, agency officials said.

There are a lot of protections that surround mental health data and juvenile mental health data, ML Calcote, assistant general counsel for DPS, said in a statement.

Experts, including county juvenile probation department officials and a former longtime juvenile judge, say the 2009 state law did not take into account the complexities of the juvenile justice system in Texas, which places strict limits on what records can be reported.

Following questions about reporting requirements from ProPublica and the Tribune, the state agency tasked with helping local courts abide by new laws moved to update its official guidance to clerks to make clear that the mental health reporting requirement applies to juveniles as well. A spokesperson for the Office of Court Administration shared a draft version of supplementary guidance that she said the office would put on its website and incorporate into future manuals.

Public Perceptions Of The Relationship Between Mental Illness And Violence

Gun Control  Gun Talks

Negative public attitudes toward persons with serious mental illnesses such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder are pervasive and persistent in the United States, and the assumption of dangerousness is a key element of this negative stereotype . A 2013 national public opinion survey found that 46% of Americans believed that persons with serious mental illness were far more dangerous than the general population. Data from the 2006 General Social Survey suggest that Americans perceive persons with schizophrenia as particularly dangerous: after reading a vignette about an individual with common symptoms of schizophrenia, 60% of respondents reported that they viewed the described individual as likely, or very likely, to be dangerous toward othersalthough the vignette description did not include any information about violent behavior or risk .

Don’t Miss: How To Reprogram Your Subconscious Mind

Nics Improvement Amendments Act Of 2007

In January 2008, President Bush signed into law the NICS Improvement Amendments Act of 2007, which, among other things:

  • Provided financial rewards and penalties to encourage states to provide to NICS information relevant to whether a person is prohibited from possessing firearms, including identifying information regarding people adjudicated as a mental defective or committed to mental institutions.21
  • Authorized grants to assist states in establishing and upgrading their reporting and background check systems.22 In order to be eligible for the grants authorized by the Act, a state had to implement a relief from disabilities program that met the Acts requirements.23

Is Anxiety Considered A Mental Illness

Occasional anxiety is OK. But anxiety disorders are different. Theyre a group of mental illnesses that cause constant and overwhelming anxiety and fear. The excessive anxiety can make you avoid work, school, family get-togethers, and other social situations that might trigger or worsen your symptoms.

You May Like: Mri Brain W Wo Contrast

Their Mental Health Records Are Not Accessible

Mental health records are overwhelmingly under-reported to the federal and state databases scanned during a background check. For example, while the majority of states now have laws that require them to submit records to the F.B.I.s National Instant Criminal Background Check System, known as NICS, there is little enforcement, and the comprehensiveness of those records vary significantly.

Mr. Obama said Tuesday that the Social Security Administration would start to look at how to link mental health records with criminal background check data. He is also requesting $500 million from Congress to improve basic mental health care.


The Aftermath Of Virginia Tech

Gov. DeWine urges gun sale background checks, mental health programs after shooting

The most tragic incident involving a states failure to report mental health records occurred in April 2007, when Virginia Tech student Seung-Hui Cho shot and killed 32 people and injured 17 others before committing suicide on the college campus in Blacksburg, Virginia. Cho was, in fact, prohibited from purchasing a firearm under federal law because of a history of mental illness.3 However, the unstable gunman was able to purchase firearms through two licensed dealers after two background checks. While Virginia law at that time required that some mental health records be submitted to the databases used for background checks, it did not require reporting of all people prohibited from possessing firearms for mental health reasons.

Don’t Miss: Mind Reader Coffee Pod Drawer

Firearm Homicide Rates Vs Total Number Of Firearm Homicides

Because the population varies significantly by city or county, firearm homicide rates provide a better illustration of the impact gun violence has on communities, rather than the total number of firearm homicides within a given area.

For example, Cook County , Illinois has by far the most number of firearm homicides out of any county in the country, averaging over 600 each year. However, because Cook County has a population of 5.2 million residents, the firearm homicide rate is much lower than many other large metro counties with smaller populations. In fact, Cook Countys firearm homicide rate is 11.62 per 100,000, ranking it 13th in the country among large central metro counties, behind Milwaukee County.12,13 Clearly, the sheer number of firearm homicides illustrates that Cook County is in the midst of a gun violence crisis, but this crisis is not unique to Chicago it is equally devastating in cities across the United States.

Increases In State Reporting

Other mass shootings, including those in Tucson, AZ, on January 8, 2011, in Aurora, CO, on July 20, 2012, and in Newtown, CT, on December 14, 2012, have also resulted in renewed calls for better laws addressing guns and mental illness. Our nations leaders, including President Obama, have joined these calls,4 and states have begun to respond.

  • The number of mental health records in NICS increased by more than 700% between the Virginia Tech shooting and January 31, 2014.5
  • As of August 31, 2021, there were over 6 million mental health records in NICS6

Since the Virginia Tech shooting, about half of the states have enacted laws authorizing and requiring the submission of mental health records to NICS, as described below. States that have enacted such laws have, in fact, subsequently submitted greater numbers of records. Of the states that had submitted the top 15 highest numbers of records as of May 2013, 14 had enacted such laws, while only two of the 15 poorest performing states had enacted such laws.7

Don’t Miss: The Emotional Life Of Your Brain

Does A Gun Background Check Include Mental Health

The system for conducting these checks is the National Instant Criminal Background Check Systemknown as the NICS. One of the databases that is checked in this system is the NICS Index, which contains data on individuals with a mental health history that prohibits them from receiving or possessing firearms.

Group Violence Intervention / Focused Deterrence

Trump Backs Federal Gun Background Checks

In the Group Violence Intervention/Focused Deterrence model, prosecutors and police work with community leaders to identify a small group of individuals who are chronic violent offenders and are at high risk for future violence. High risk individuals are called into a meeting and are told that if violence continues, every legal tool available will be used to ensure they face swift and certain consequences. These individuals are simultaneously connected to social services and community support to assist them in changing their behavior.

Evidence: An analysis of 24 focused deterrence programs found that these strategies led to an overall statistically significant reduction in firearm violence. The most successful of these programs have reduced violent crime in cities by an average of 30% and improved relations between law enforcement officers and the neighborhoods they serve.86

Don’t Miss: Mental Illness And Spirituality Connection

Predicting Risk Of Future Violence

In the aftermath of mass shootings and other violent events, the public and policymakers look for answers to the question of how such an event could have been prevented. When the perpetrator is reported to have had a mental illness, questions arise about why he was not identified and treated before committing a major act of violence. The issue of predicting risk of future violence among people with mental illness is central to the development of policy responses to mental illness and violence. Policies intended to keep guns out of the hands of people with mental illness who are likely to be violent depend on clinicians to accurately identify which individuals are likely to be violent. However, research evidence shows that risk prediction, particularly for statistically rare events like mass shootings, is a very inexact science.

Appealing A Denial Based On Medical Records

Nevertheless, if a persons application is denied by the police, they have the right to appeal the gun permit decision. Within 30 days, the individual must file an appeal with the New Jersey Superior Court alongside a $50.00 filing fee. Upon receipt of the appeal, the Court will schedule a hearing date. Generally, the first appearance is a status conference to inform the Judge if each party is ready to proceed or if additional time is needed. From there, the Court will set a trial date. If a person is denied a permit because of a physical or mental concern, an appeal is their best option to obtain the permit. Furthermore, at the trial, the applicant, depending on their condition, should call an appropriate doctor, psychiatrist, or some type of expert as a witness in order to explain to the Judge that he or she is capable of safely handling a firearm. Due to the complexity of these issues, it is important to seek help from an experienced NJ firearms attorney.

Don’t Miss: Symptoms Of Acoustic Neuroma Pressing On Brain Stem

How Does The Background Check System Work

When either of those two things happens in Florida, the court or government body that made the decision on the individuals mental health is required to report that record to a state law enforcement agency or the FBI.

The records would be in the National Instant Criminal Background Check System, a confidential database that houses the names and birth years of individuals ineligible to buy firearms.

A licensed gun dealer is required under federal law to run potential buyers through the criminal background check system. The process usually takes around 90 seconds, and, if all the records are in the right place, would prevent a purchaser who was previously involuntarily committed or adjudicated as mentally incompetent from getting the gun.

But federal law doesnt require states to make these mental health records part of background check system, and many fail to voluntarily report the records.

And licensed gun shops arent the only places to buy a firearm.

You could buy guns from someone from an online classified ad, people at a yard sale or on the street corner selling guns, or people who are at a gun show but not a retail dealer, all without having to pass a background check, according to Ari Freilich, a legal expert with the Giffords Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence, a group that promotes gun control.

History Of This Program

States move to require reporting of mental health records to FBI gun background check database

The national background check system was established as part of the 1993 Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act. Gun stores, pawn shops and others licensed dealers nationwide must use it when someone wants to purchase a firearm.

Prospective gun buyers must fill out a form from the Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco Firearms and Explosives attesting to certain questions, then their name is run through the FBI system.

The FBI says more than 300 million checks have been made over time, leading to more than 2 million denials.

More:McConnell ‘supportive’ of bipartisan gun reform framework in key boost for congressional response to mass shootings

Holes in the mental health reporting system gained attention in 2007 after a shooting at Virginia Tech left 32 dead. Two years earlier, a court had found the student shooter an imminent danger to self or others after he was accused of stalking two female classmates, resulting in temporary detention that should have disqualified him from purchasing firearms.

At the time, only about half of the states reported mental health records to NICS. By 2012, that number had shrunk to about 19 states that reported fewer than 100 records and by 2014 it fell to eight. In 2016, it fell to four until Alaska increased its reporting.

The National Shooting Sports Foundation continues to lobby in New Hampshire, Montana and Wyoming to tighten up the reporting.

More:What Russian ammo ban? Loophole keeps it on US shelves, splitting gun rights groups

Don’t Miss: How To Remove Brain Fog

Your Ffl Transfer Fee

What is the FFL transfer fee when buying a gun from a Federal Firearms License holder?

The short answer is, it depends. The FFL transfer fee depends on the FFL holder and state and local regulations for background checks. However, typically we see FFL transfer fees between $15-25 per firearm NFA items may be double that fee.

The federal government does not charge for background checks to buy a firearm. Background checks are not done by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives . The BATF only regulates firearms and license holders. The FBI does the background checks and does not charge an FFL transfer fee. “The FBI does not charge a fee for conducting NICS checks. However, States that act as points of contact for NICS checks may charge a fee consistent with State law,” says the BATF.

Required Training For Purchasing Or Possessing Handguns

Data for this figure were drawn from research by the Giffords Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence.

State implementation data valid as of January 1, 2021.

As of January 1, 2021, seven states and the District of Columbia have laws requiring individuals to undergo some sort of safety training prior to being able to purchase, or in the case of Connecticut, carry, a firearm. California and Massachusetts have laws requiring such training for the purchase of both handguns and long guns. The District of Columbia’s law, which applies to handguns and long guns, goes further: It requires safety training prior to registration, and registration is required for possession of a firearm thus, the training requirement applies to not only people purchasing new firearms but also people moving into the District who already own firearms. The laws in Connecticut, Hawaii, Maryland, and Rhode Island apply only to handguns. Washington’s law applies to semiautomatic rifles. Elements of safety training laws may include specifics about instructor qualifications or training, information about which organizations may offer approved courses, curriculum requirements, and a requirement that trainees pass a written test.

Originally published April 22, 2020

Read Also: Diffuse Large B-cell Lymphoma Brain Symptoms

The Effects Of Firearm Safety Training Requirements

According to results from a 2015 survey, approximately 61 percent of firearm owners in the United States have received formal training on firearm safety and use . Others receive informal training from their friends or family. Although there are no federal laws requiring private citizens to receive safety training, states sometimes require gun purchasers or those requesting concealed-carry permits to show proof of formal safety training on how to safely store, use, and maintain weapons. Public support for requiring concealed-carry applicants to pass a test demonstrating safe and lawful use of firearms is relatively high an estimated 74 percent of U.S. adults supported such requirements in a 2021 survey . Advocates of such policies suggest that the regulations ensure a minimum competency for using guns safely, just as drivers’ tests are used to determine whether a person can safely drive a car. However, detractors of the laws suggest that such regulations create unwarranted costs and barriers to firearm ownership and that the right to own a firearm should not be conditional on training .

Related articles

Serenity Mental Health Centers Denver

How Much Does A Registered Nurse Make At Serenity Healthcare In...

Western Mental Health Marshall Mn

Integrity Teamwork A Passion For Helping Others ...

Mental Health Short Term Disability

Searching For Accredited Dual Diagnosis Mental Health Centers Near You ...

Mental Health Self Care Gift Basket

Stress Relief Gift Basket Ideas For Mental Health ...